Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
2 points by CatDancer 5434 days ago | link | parent

It's fairly tedious to be doing this in Scheme, isn't it? We might let Scheme handle implementing the low level readc, and then in Arc redefine readc to be a more advanced function that can take an optional argument:

  (let original readc
    (= readc (fn ((o str (stdin)))
               (original str))))

  arc> (fromstring "abc" (readc))
  #\a
That pattern could be made into a macro:

  (mac redef (name args . body)
    `(let original ,name
       (= ,name (fn ,args ,@body))))
which makes writing the enhanced version of readc look like:

  (redef readc ((o str (stdin)))
    (original str))


1 point by absz 5434 days ago | link

redef is already in Anarki; arc.arc, line 2446:

  (mac redef (name parms . body)
    " Redefine a function.  The old function definition may be used within
      `body' as the name `old'. "
    `(do (tostring
          (let old (varif ,name nilfn)
            (= ,name (fn ,parms ,@body))))
         ,name))
It's the same as yours, except (a) it suppresses the warning on re-assigning an identifier, and (b) it calls the original function old.

-----

2 points by CatDancer 5434 days ago | link

suppressing the warning doesn't appear to be necessary with =

  arc> (def foo () 3)
  #<procedure: foo>
  arc> (= foo 4)
  4
  arc>

-----

1 point by absz 5433 days ago | link

I was wondering if that was necessary... I think redef used to use set, which is why it was there.

-----