Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
I'm losing track of replies to me on the Arc Forum
7 points by CatDancer 6406 days ago | 9 comments
I'm losing track of replies people make to me on my posts and comments I've written. I can click on the "threads" link, but it shows (I think) the latest posts first and the complete tree of replies to replies, so if someone makes a reply to an older post or comment of mine it is far down in the "threads" list and I'm starting to miss them.


7 points by kens 6406 days ago | link

I'm hoping that some day internet forums will have the functionality of Usenet c. 1985.

In particular, the system should keep track of which messages I've read, and just show me new messages.

-----

4 points by nex3 6406 days ago | link

I always use the "comments" page. Sometimes it's annoying to sort out the stuff I don't want to read, but I don't tend to miss any replies.

-----

3 points by CatDancer 6406 days ago | link

That's a good idea.

How about an RSS feed for the comments page?

-----

5 points by akkartik 6405 days ago | link

Or better: http://hystry.com/newsyc/follow/?arc,CatDancer

Prior discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=79694

Update: Ah, I see somebody already pointed you to it (http://arclanguage.org/item?id=3919). The point of the UI is that new replies to threads you were involved in will show up in reverse chronological order with all their context (parent comments).

-----

1 point by CatDancer 6405 days ago | link

Whoa, awesome! Nice job!

I actually didn't click through on lojic's comment, I'm sorry to say, from "old news" I assumed the link was to someone else complaining about the same thing, not pointing to a fix!

-----

1 point by akkartik 6405 days ago | link

Thanks! Unfortunate that news.yc went through a revision on the day you became aware of hystry. Hmm, perhaps I should crawl arclanguage and news.yc with separate crawlers even if it's the same code.

(Ulterior motive in writing this reply: to make sure parent gets crawled by hystry after restarting :)

-----

1 point by eds 6406 days ago | link

There are two "comments" links, one at the top of the page for all new comments, and one at the bottom of your profile page for all comments you posted.

I find the personal "comments" page very useful for finding all responses to comments I posted.

-----

1 point by lojic 6406 days ago | link

Old news :)

http://arclanguage.com/item?id=1002

As kens said, it's hard to beat good old usenet. Reading comp.lang.lisp is much easier for completeness. Now if the forum had a filtering mechanism a la slashdot for me to only look at comments with a certain point threshold, I'd be happier. I think I'll make that a separate post ( http://arclanguage.com/item?id=3920 ).

I just stopped checking my older threads - if someone leaves a comment on an old item, there's no way I'm going to invest the time to go looking for it.

-----

2 points by absz 6406 days ago | link

As am I; it might be nicer for a reply to bump its tree up to the top, which would seem to obviate the problem.

-----