Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
2 points by zck 3145 days ago | link | parent

It's not backwards compatible. Hence me trying to get feedback before pushing the 1.0.

The specific backwards incompatibility (I assume you got "We can't parse this as a suite body") is moving from this format for the tests:

    (suite suite-name
           test-name (test-body))
to the format you suggested last year:

    (suite suite-name
           (test test-name (test-body)))
I don't think supporting both ways of writing tests is useful. I'm also planning on migrating the anarki tests when I roll out the 1.0. Actually, I could get started on a branch even before. That'd be something to do.


1 point by akkartik 3145 days ago | link

Ah, I'd forgotten :)

Yeah, no reason to be compatible. I was just confused. I'll migrate the tests to the new format, and update Anarki publicly once you release 1.0.

-----

2 points by zck 3144 days ago | link

If you start doing some of the migration work, push the in-progress stuff to a branch and I'll help work on it. I'll do the same if I get to it before you. Thanks.

-----

2 points by akkartik 3144 days ago | link

I spent a few minutes trying to build an automatic script to upgrade our tests -- and found a bug in Arc's serialize/unserialize (my fault) :)

https://github.com/arclanguage/anarki/commit/9efd58992d

What's the equivalent of (run-all-suites) in 1.0? I didn't see this covered in the Readme.

Other than that my script seems to be barfing on nested suites at the moment. I'll continue working on it tomorrow.

-----

2 points by zck 3144 days ago | link

Oh, fancy writing a script to do the upgrade. It'd be cool to see it.

You can run all tests with (test). I should add that to the instructions, thanks.

-----

2 points by akkartik 3143 days ago | link

This must be the most fun thing on my radar right now, because I got to it first thing this morning :)

  ; translate.arc
  (def translate (expr)
    (accum acc
      (translate-2 expr acc)))

  (def translate-2 (expr acc)
    (if (atom expr)
          (acc expr)
        (is car.expr 'suite)
          (do (acc 'suite)
              (let (suite-name . suite-body)  cdr.expr
                (acc suite-name)
                (translate-suite-body suite-body acc)))
        (is car.expr 'suite-w/setup)
          (do (acc 'suite-w/setup)
              (let (suite-name suite-setup . suite-body)  cdr.expr
                (acc suite-name)
                (acc suite-setup)
                (translate-suite-body suite-body acc)))
        'else
          (map acc expr)))

  (def translate-suite-body (suite-body acc)
    (if suite-body
      (if (acons car.suite-body)
        ; nested suite
        (let (nested-suite . rest) suite-body
          (acc (accum acc2
                  (translate-2 nested-suite acc2)))
          (translate-suite-body rest acc))
        ; test name must be atomic
        (let (test-name test-body . rest)  suite-body
          (acc `(test ,test-name ,test-body))
          (translate-suite-body rest acc)))))

  ; bootstrap tests for a test harness :)
  ; suite with tests
  (assert:iso '(suite a (test t1 b1) (test t2 b2))
              (translate '(suite a t1 b1 t2 b2)))

  ; suite with tests and nested suites
  (assert:iso '(suite a (test t1 b1) (suite s2 (test t3 b3)) (test t2 b2))
              (translate '(suite a t1 b1 (suite s2 t3 b3) t2 b2)))

  ; suite with setup and tests
  (assert:iso '(suite-w/setup a (x 1 y 2) (test t1 b1) (test t2 b2))
              (translate '(suite-w/setup a (x 1 y 2) t1 b1 t2 b2)))

  ; suite with setup and tests and nested suites
  (assert:iso '(suite-w/setup a (x 1 y 2) (test t1 b1) (suite s2 (test t3 b3)) (test t2 b2))
              (translate '(suite-w/setup a (x 1 y 2) t1 b1 (suite s2 t3 b3) t2 b2)))

  ; run
  (each f cdr.argv
    (prn f)
    (fromfile string.f
      (tofile (+ string.f ".2")
        (each expr (drain:read)
          (let out translate.expr
            (ppr out))))))

Run it like so:

  $ arc translate.arc *.t lib/*.t lib/tests/*
I haven't committed it anywhere yet because I'm not too happy with the state of Anarki's pretty-printer. Would you mind if I change the indentation style for suites and tests in Anarki? I was thinking something like this:

  (suite atom
    (test includes-int (assert-t (atom 3)))
    (test includes-float
      (assert-t (atom 3.14159)))
    (test includes-exact (assert-t (atom 3/16)))
    (test includes-symbol (assert-t (atom 'a)))
    (test includes-char (assert-t (atom #\a)))
    (test includes-string
      (assert-t (atom "hello")))
    (test includes-nil (assert-t (atom nil)))
    (test excludes-list
      (assert-nil (atom '(1 2 3))))
    (test excludes-table
      (assert-nil (atom (obj a 1 b 2))))
    (test excludes-tagged-types
      (assert-nil (atom (annotate 'foo 34)))))
..rather than this current output:

  (suite atom
         (test includes-int (assert-t (atom 3)))
         (test includes-float
               (assert-t (atom 3.14159)))
         (test includes-exact (assert-t (atom 3/16)))
         (test includes-symbol (assert-t (atom 'a)))
         (test includes-char (assert-t (atom #\a)))
         (test includes-string
               (assert-t (atom "hello")))
         (test includes-nil (assert-t (atom nil)))
         (test excludes-list
               (assert-nil (atom '(1 2 3))))
         (test excludes-table
               (assert-nil (atom (obj a 1 b 2))))
         (test excludes-tagged-types
               (assert-nil (atom (annotate 'foo 34)))))

-----

2 points by akkartik 3143 days ago | link

All done:

  atom:  	10 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  memtable:  	5 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  do:  	2 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  for:  	3 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  ssyntax:  	13 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  ...
  strings:  	0 tests,  	15 nested suites.
      trim:  	4 tests,  	0 nested suites.
      tokens:  	2 tests,  	0 nested suites.
      endmatch:  	4 tests,  	0 nested suites.
      subst:  	3 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  ...
  types:  	0 tests,  	3 nested suites.
      coerce:  	2 tests,  	1 nested suite.
          strings:  	9 tests,  	5 nested suites.
              numbers:  	6 tests,  	3 nested suites.
                  rational-rounds-with-unused-base-arg:  	6 tests,  	0 nested suites.
                  rational-rounds-to-even:  	6 tests,  	0 nested suites.
                  float-rounds-to-even:  	6 tests,  	0 nested suites.
              characters:  	4 tests,  	0 nested suites.
              coercions-to-same-type:  	3 tests,  	0 nested suites.
              string->num:  	18 tests,  	0 nested suites.
              string->int:  	13 tests,  	0 nested suites.
      type:  	15 tests,  	0 nested suites.
      annotation:  	4 tests,  	0 nested suites.
  Suite module: all 3 tests passed!
  Suite special-syntax: all 4 tests passed!
  Suite html: the single test passed!
  There are no tests directly in suite special-forms.
      Suite special-forms.function-definition: all 22 tests passed!
      Suite special-forms.if: all 5 tests passed!
      Suite special-forms.quasiquote: all 15 tests passed!
      Suite special-forms.quote: all 3 tests passed!
      Suite special-forms.assign: all 3 tests passed!
  There are no tests directly in suite types.
      Suite types.coerce: all 2 tests passed!
          Suite types.coerce.strings: all 9 tests passed!
              Suite types.coerce.strings.numbers: all 6 tests passed!
                  Suite types.coerce.strings.numbers.rational-rounds-with-unused-base-arg: all 6 tests passed!
                  Suite types.coerce.strings.numbers.rational-rounds-to-even: all 6 tests passed!
                  Suite types.coerce.strings.numbers.float-rounds-to-even: all 6 tests passed!
              Suite types.coerce.strings.characters: all 4 tests passed!
              Suite types.coerce.strings.coercions-to-same-type: all 3 tests passed!
              Suite types.coerce.strings.string->num: all 18 tests passed!
              Suite types.coerce.strings.string->int: all 13 tests passed!
      Suite types.type: all 15 tests passed!
      Suite types.annotation: all 4 tests passed!
  Suite len: all 3 tests passed!
  Suite bracket-fn: all 3 tests passed!
  ...

  Yay! All 606 tests passed!

-----