A great reminder for me about the importance of profiling, thanks for posting!
I have a less technical confession of stupidity to make: I was feeling a little disappointed by the rate of submissions on this forum the last few days, when I realized I was only checking the front page and not the new submissions page. Now I look forward to reading what I've missed. :)
Thanks evanrmurphy. It's almost like there are two communities here, with the second one visible to (and probably only interesting to) those willing to poke around a bit. The front page skips the detailed discussions and has become more of a summary of the cool stuff people are doing with arc. The new page is more like a traditional forum.
As a luxury of being so small, this community encourages all sorts of questions and discussion[1] (and angst :) - but without karma. Compare the boost 'Ask HN' posts get on HN; HN has to either encourage or discourage discussion; its size makes it hard to do much else.
As a luxury of being so small, this community encourages all sorts of questions and discussion...but without karma. Compare the boost 'Ask HN' posts get on HN; HN has to either encourage or discourage discussion; its size makes it hard to do much else.
I made one Ask HN post that didn't get a single comment. Surprising how a community a tiny fraction of the size can be more responsive in some ways.
Maybe that shouldn't be surprising though, since responsiveness tends to be inversely proportional to size in so many things [1]. When there are many people using the site it's tempting to think, "Well someone has got to respond to my post!" But there is much more posting happening on large sites too, and different rules emerge (e.g. HN culture's greater emphasis on karma, as you suggest).
[1] Committees, web browsers, vehicles, mammals...
Yeah, I normally check comments first and then new, since comments change the most, and new second most. This forum doesn't have enough traffic right now to need to sort by popularity.
It's funny, I never would've used the comments page on HN, but its utility is clear here. Traffic is a significant variable in usability on these sites, even though they're clones of one another.
